chargeback reason code 71. 4853 – Cardholder Dispute – Credit Posted as a Purchase. chargeback reason code 71

 
 4853 – Cardholder Dispute – Credit Posted as a Purchasechargeback reason code 71  The list of chargeback reason codes in this article is organized by card brand and type of dispute

Level Up Your Chargeback Disputes with Social Media Clues. In other words: if you want to prevent forking over more revenue in the end due to chargeback fees, a simple, easy refund policy is the right way to go. 4853 – Cardholder Dispute – Goods or Services Not Provided. Most processors will verify that an authorization approval was issued, in which case this type of. It depends on the chargeback reason code associated with the dispute. From there, a merchant can accept the chargeback or take action through the representment process to attempt to have the chargeback reversed. Code. Reason Code Reason Code North-America Reason Description; 4540: F29: Card Not Present (fraud). 2. ©UA01 Fraud – Card Present Transaction. Each of these causes has a designated “reason code,” and banks assign the appropriate code to. Also, just like American Express, Discover functions as both a card network and an. Each of these causes has a designated “reason code,” and banks assign the. Date Option. There are dozens of reasons why cardholders and issuers dispute transactions. She later changes her mind and cancels her order for which she didn’t receive the code. EMV has been a mostly global standard since 2004. 02/10/16 Added Debit Chargeback Reason Codes. 5 Proven Tactics to Win. 1. Cancelled Recurring Billing (17. 1. 4. Pursuant to the Fair Credit Billing Act of 1974, cardholders have the right to dispute unauthorized or erroneous charges, and issuing banks must reverse a disputed transaction if the cardholder’s claim is valid. Authorization related Chargeback: 4834:. Fight; Prevent;. For each reason code, a definition is Chargeback Reason Codes Page 1 of 5 Card Type Reason Code Reason Text Chargeback Category Preventable Reversible MASTERCARD 4802 Requested/Required Item Illegible or Missing Request for Information YES YES MASTERCARD 4803 Documentation received was invalid/incomplete Request for Information YES YES 5 Categories of Visa Chargeback Reason Codes. com . A fraud filter is any technology designed to analyze transaction data and flag commonly-recognized signs of fraud. The sales receipt and/or date and amount of the authorization if other than the transaction date. Chargeback reason code 11. Message. For example, suppose a cardholder filed a case about an order processing issue, and you disputed the chargeback. By entering your email, you agree to receive marketing emails from Shopify. Eventually the existing chargeback reason codes won't be used and will be removed from this guide. 4853 Cardholder Dispute. Code. Vantage HouseEthoca alerts can prevent chargebacks before they hit your bank account. In simple terms, Mastercard Chargeback Reason Code 4859 — No Show/Addendum/ATM Dispute refers to situations where a customer claims the services purchased from a merchant were not fulfilled. By understanding the reason behind the chargeback, you can gather the necessary evidence to support your case effectively. 11, 16. As we touched on earlier, chargebacks can happen due to technical errors. High Level Visa Chargeback Dispute Flow. According to research, actual fraud or online shoplifters accounts for only 29-30% of total fraud losses for e-commerce which is a criminal fraud. NEW. In that way, winning one dispute may help prevent the next chargeback to come after it. That suggests that in the times when merchants. Chargeback. 3 falls under the “Authorization” category. Chargeback reason code. Description of Change Where to Look • Require cardholder letter, email or Expedited Dispute Form in first chargebacks for Cardholder Disputes reason codes involving2. 10. Chapter 2 1. 13. 1? Visa chargeback reason code 12. • Chargeback – a message sent via the card brand network to debit the merchant and credit the issuer for a cardholder dispute. This code is used when a cardholder claims that a fraudulent transaction occurred in a face-to-face environment, such as a retail store. He then pays with his credit card which shows a denial so he presents another card to the merchant. November 5, 2023. We’ve all been there as an eCommerce owner: you excitedly ship out a $1,500 order to a customer, and then a few weeks later you’re notified that the customer has opened a chargeback dispute. Updated August 23, 2023. In particular, as far as Reason Code 71 is concerned, they should immediately stop a transaction for which an authorization is declined and ask the customer for another form of payment. 634. Mastercard: n/a This chargeback is caused by Authorization. • Section 4: Chargeback Reason Codes—Contains detailed information on the reason codes for the most common types of chargebacks that merchants receive. 4 Other Fraud—Card Absent Environment – a common friendly fraud reason code, especially when the cardholder doesn’t recognize the transaction on their statement. Chargeback reason codes 71 and 4808 are caused when merchants ignore a declined authorization response from the issuer and attempt one of the following actions: Forced posting. Visa chargeback reason code 71 falls under the “Authorization” category. Code 4871 chargebacks usually occur when a fraudster with a stolen credit card targets a merchant whose POS terminals don't support PIN entry or convinces the merchant to bypass the PIN requirement. 02/10/16 Added Debit Chargeback Reason Codes. 6 Duplicate Processing/Paid by Other Means. MasterCard: Reason Code 4859 Services not rendered. If the order was genuinely not as described, then the cardholder has a case. For example, 10. 1. The following scenarios can also result in code 12. 3 Changed Discover Reason Codes to match what is shown in the UI. 1: 10: Fraud: EMV Liability Shift Non-counterfeit Fraud: 10. 1. ” This reason code is used when a transaction is posted to the wrong account number. Protect stored cardholder data. All of Visa’s existing reason codes. The following is an inside and out diagram of reason codes for Visa, MasterCard, Discover & Amex alongside their depiction. Chargeback reason American Express reason code Discover reason code Mastercard reason code Visa reason code; Cancelled subscription: C28: NF: 4841: 13. It is very similar to: Mastercard's 4853- Defective/Not as Described Reason Code. In simple terms, an Electronic Commerce Indicator (ECI) is basically a 3-D Secure response code. In this instance, the cardholder claims a misrepresentation of the order they received, such as a defect, damage, counterfeit, or incomplete merchandise. 6: Duplicate processing/Paid by other means. 13. Different card networks have different reason code systems. Another thing you should bear in mind is that the card brand involved in the dispute can also change the reason code to suit new developments. 1 Chargebacks A chargeback is a rules-based mechanism, with time-sensitive workflows, that enables the issuer and the acquirer to determine the financial liability of a disputed transaction. Transaction was approved by the Issuer knowing that the authentication data failed verification and was not reliable. ” This code indicates that the merchant sent an authorization approval request for a transaction, received a “Decline” or “Pick Up Card” response, and submitted the transaction anyway. Make sure your entire team is on the same page. It is used as a form of proof that the person attempting to use the card has the physical card in their possession. Response to retrieval request: Based on the information provided, the acquiring and issuing banks resolve the dispute, if possible. Receiving a damaged product. 11/03/15 Updated these MasterCard Chargeback Codes: 08, 12, 31, 34, 42, 53, 55, 59, 60, 70, 71. There are plenty of reasons as to why this would happen, hence the many. The cardholder claims either that the merchandise was never received, or the services purchased were not provided. When a customer who's enrolled with 3-D Secure from their bank initiates a purchase, the tool will deploy during the checkout. However, the 30 day waiting period can be waived if you’ve. A chargeback happens when a customer asks their card-issuing bank to reverse a transaction. There are five main categories of Visa chargeback reason codes: Fraudulent Transactions, Authorization Issues, Processing Errors, Consumer Disputes, and Other Chargeback Categories. Cancelled Recurring Billing - 71 is an American Express Chargeback Reason Code that merchants and e-commerce sellers should be aware of. See the charts below for the full listing. Chargeback. A chargeback is the potential outcome of a disputed credit or debit card transaction. Now, compliance cases go through Visa Resolve Online (VROL). 4630 . The reason code also presents a timeline to fight the chargeback and what evidence is needed to reverse the chargeback. Assemble Your Evidence. 7 Message Reason. Clerical Reason Code 71: Declined Authorization. The chargeback can be for the total transaction amount or a lesser amount. [noun]/* kə • stə • mər • di • spyo͞ot/. The shorthand description is “No Authorization. Chargeback Reason Codes Retrieval Reason Codes 78 Int'l only Service Violation Code Discover 4541 AP 4586 AW 4755 RG 4553 RM 8002 RN2 Altered Amount Non-Receipt of Goods or Services0Cardholder. So, if a customer files an Amex chargeback, the company has good reason to side with their customer over the merchant. Both EFM and ECM measure compliance at the MID level. Each bank card network has its owner list of reason codes banks must prefer from. Europe Region Operations Bulletin No. Chargeback stands If you don’t reply in time or with the right documentation, the Chargeback will stand. 4. American Express Chargeback Codes (2023) American Express functions as a card network and an issuing bank. Now, compliance cases must be submitted through Visa Resolve Online (VROL). Terms and conditions. The charge you submitted did not receive a valid authorization approval code for the amount of the charge. Mastercard Chargeback Reason Code 70: Chip Liability Shift. There are 151 chargeback reason codes across the four major card networks. Despite all the rules and guidelines, the outcomes of the chargeback process can be, at times, subjective, and can vary based on the scenario, merchant payment. Each chargeback received a numeric code which is known as the “reason code”. Reason. Every chargeback is filed with a reason code that identifies the given reason for the dispute. Eligible Chargeback Reason Codes . Valid Values/Format: 22 - First Chargeback Handling Fee. 4: Other Fraud–Card-Absent Environment. UA02 Fraud – Card Not Present Transaction. Chargeback Reason Codes Retrieval Reason Codes 78 Int'l only Service Violation Code Discover 4541 AP 4586 AW 4755 RG 4553 RM 8002 RN2 Altered Amount Non-Receipt of Goods or Services0Cardholder Disputes Quality of Goods or Services MasterCard;45 Days from the central processing date of the transaction120 Days from the central processing date of. A new 4 byte reason code will be used moving forward. Look below the surface. F02. These codes are currently defined within the ANSI X9. These companies can also handle the entire representment process. Visa’s chargeback reason code 13. 71 (3) Removed. Protect cardholder data. Most acquiring banks put a timeframe on when customers can initiate a chargeback for a purchase. Valid chargeback reason codes are defined in UDC 03B/CB. Which is meant to know the reason for the dispute. Reason Code 04. Dispute Condition Description Dispute Condition Code Category Code Category Code Description; EMV Liability Shift: 10. Visa chargeback reason code 72 falls under the “Authorization” category. The shorthand description is “Insufficient Reply. 11, 16. However, it is important to note that this reason code is based on the reason given by the customer to their bank. 4841 Canceled Recurring or Digital Goods Transactions. These codes are broken down into five different category. Specifically, these updates only pertain to transactions that are charged back after Oct. 5: Visa Fraud Monitoring Program. ”. Some legacy codes are no longer supported by a chargeback reason. Mastercard Chargeback Reason Code 73: Duplicate Transaction. Each chargeback received a numeric code which is known as the “reason code”. A chargeback reason code is a two- or four-digit alphanumeric code issuing banks assign to disputes. This provided a number of insights into the typical. 5. 2. Chargeback Reason Codes 85 and 4860 may be caused because the merchant: Did not issue a credit. This reason code is used when the cardholder claims that their card was used fraudulently without their permission. ”. Accessed October 31, 2022. This manual outlines the rules and guidelines to be followed by the members. ”. In some cases, errors can be resolved and reversed, but there is no equivalent to chargeback representment when it comes to ACH. The good news is that most of these invalid claims are disputable by the merchant. Then they instruct the merchant’s acquiring bank to reverse the transaction and withdraw the funds from the merchant account. 6 Message Reason Code 71—Transaction Amount Differs. Let’s say you got a Visa chargeback with reason code 13. [MasterCard Reason Codes 4853, 4855, 4859;. chargeback: The buyer filed a chargeback with the credit card issuer. 1? Visa chargeback reason code 11. Pre-arbitration gives the acquirer and issuer. To avoid the reason code 71 you can simply deposit the sales receipt on time to the acquirer. Visa Chargeback Reason Code 10. But, merchants should be aware that, eventually, everyone will be required to use the new designations. These numeric codes vary via card brands, yet all hypothetically fill the same need: to provide explanation behind the chargeback dispute. Card issuers and card networks deem certain chargeback codes to be nearly indisputable by merchants, and as a result, a merchant can be charged a fee of up to $500 by card networks for submitting a dispute of such chargebacks. 3. 71 Authorization Request Declined 72 No Authorization 73 Expired Card 74 Late Presentment71: Declined Authorization. 4846 — Incorrect Currency Code. Category. 13. The ECI value tells you what to do next in a 3DS transaction — proceed, reject the purchase, or try again. Effective for Transactions completed on or after 15 April 2016, A Transaction for which. It happens when. In simple terms, VCR introduced five definitive changes to the dispute resolution process: The timeframe for merchant response was shortened from 45 days to 30 days. While there are many chargeback reason codes, all chargebacks fall into one of three categories: The chargeback period, or the time limit for filing a chargeback, depends on the card scheme and the chargeback reason code. Visa groups its chargeback codes into four main categories—fraud, authorization, processing errors, and customer disputes. UA01 Fraud – Card Present Transaction. In these situations, a merchant’s billing descriptor is simply not recognized by the customer. 0: Updated report version from 1. 04/09/14 Discover: DC, U02. Click on “report a problem” and select the transaction in question. S. 71 (1) Declined Authorization. This list was generated 5/4/2022. MasterCard chargeback reason code 4540. A Charge is Disputed * We’ll work directly with the Card Member and try to resolve the case before reaching out to you. The portion of fraud taking place in mobile channels jumped in 2021, more than tripling from 8% of US retail fraud in 2020 to 27% in 2021. But cardholders and merchants have different time limits. R03 Insufficient Reply. According to Nilson, 56% of global card transactions were done on Visa in 2015. Reason Code 71 designates chargebacks resulting when the card issuer receives a transaction for which authorization has been declined. By entering your email, you agree to receive marketing emails from Shopify. up under any number of different chargeback . At Visa they used to receive reason code 98. 3 is an updated version of legacy Visa reason code 72, which was phased out under the Visa Claims Resolution initiative. By entering your email, you agree to receive marketing emails from Shopify. The shorthand description is “Card Recovery Bulletin or Exception File. 3. NEW. Code 13. 4853 – Cardholder Dispute – Digital Goods Purchase of $25 or Less. This can provide important information to fight the dispute. The list of chargeback reason codes in this article is organized by card brand and type of dispute. PRICE code. Chargeback Reason Codes Reason code are the first key to understanding the root causes . 2 falls under the “Authorization” category. In this instance, the cardholder claims a misrepresentation of the order they received, such as a defect, damage, counterfeit, or incomplete merchandise. 4 spec (Section 8. Technical. Explanation. . However, for simplification, they are divided into eight categories:. 38%. many chargeback reason codes that exist today. 2134. REQUEST A DEMO. UA05 Fraud – Chip Counterfeit Transaction. This list was generated 5/4/2022. Visa Chargeback Reason Codes. Overall returns (all codes): 15%. See our Automated Clearing House (ACH) support article if you are looking for ACH Return Codes. ). Our article covers the most common chargeback codes, including what they mean, how to prevent them, and how to dispute them if necessary. It can range from 60 to 120 days from the billing date. 4? Visa chargeback reason code 12. . This code tells you why the customer or bank initiated the dispute. 7: Defective goods and services: C32: RM: 13. There is no one-size-fits-all when fighting chargebacks. Visa uses the four main categories to organize its reason codes: Authorization, Card Member Disputes (which Visa refers to as Consumer Disputes), Fraud, and Processing Errors. However, it also encompasses scenarios like. At this stage,. Using the same link provided above, contact PayPal to report the scam. American Express is incentivized to keep their customers happy. Fraudulent Activity. Unfortunately, the final decision in such cases comes down to the issuing bank, and not. This ranges anywhere from roughly 60 to 90 days after purchase. Try Shopify free for 3 days, no credit card required. 7: Defective goods and services: C32: RM: 13. Laundering: The merchant carried out transactions without a legitimate cardholder’s involvement. Reason Code 12. September 2011: 5. A risk department can accurately analyze what the issue is with their merchant by seeing the individual reason code,” Cirone explained. The reason_code will be one of the following values: chargeback_reimbursement: The gross shows positive if the chargeback was resolved in the seller's favor, and the seller gets a refund. Fraud. 10. 4% of all transactions worldwide are made with EMV chip cards, which has led to a precipitous drop in card-present fraud. A false decline on a credit card or debit transaction occurs when a legitimate card purchase is rejected by mistake. A customer payment dispute, more commonly called a “chargeback,” happens when a cardholder disputes (challenges) a payment card transaction and asks the card-issuing bank to reverse it. Effective for Transactions completed on or after 15 April 2016, A Transaction for which Authorization was obtained after a Decline Response was received for the same purchase. Download our 100+ page comprehensive guide to reason codes, modifiers, time limits, and compelling evidence. 2. Further information at page PSR-564, 11. In addition to Reason Codes changing as a result of the VCR program, each Reason Code is now associated with a new Reason Category. 4 chargebacks:The customer can raise a dispute against any transaction. . To help merchants understand the underlying issue of each chargeback, American Express has created specific chargeback reason codes to help business owners interpret chargebacks. Once you understand the reason code associated with a chargeback, you can understand the root cause of the dispute and submit a response that includes the. 4808: This code can refer to: Account Number Not on File. We are writing to dispute the $1980 chargeback with the chargeback reason code 30 Services Not Provided or Merchandise Not Received. Reason Code 76 – Incorrect. Use fallback options—like manually entering transaction data—as a last resort. You double and triple check your customer service records to see if the customer wrote in about the shipment (they haven’t), you check the tracking. Chargeback reason codes are codes used to categorize the reason for the dispute. In the case where goods or services are to be delivered, Cardholders can disputeChargeback reason code 4853 can be used to indicate disputes where the cardholder simply claims that the merchant never delivered on what was promised. ” But, there is still a process users can go through to recover their money in the event of a genuine, unauthorized transfer, as in the case of account takeover, for example. 71 - Declined Authorization. Description of Change Where to Look • Require cardholder letter, email or Expedited Dispute Form in first chargebacks for Cardholder Disputes reason codes involvingThe Fintech Times. If the cardholder’s bank accepts the dispute, they will reverse the transaction, taking the funds back from the merchant and. It is subject to change and may not include every currently known dispute reason code. . 3 is part of an updated and expanded revision of the legacy codes that indicated fraud, codes which were phased out under the Visa Claims Resolution initiative. 2 may be able to represent the transaction and reverse the chargeback with the right compelling evidence. S. Top-3 Visa Dispute Reason Codes. Chargeback reason codes apply to disputes, between a cardholder (customer) and a merchant, when the dispute has escalated to a chargeback. Having a Lax Attitude Toward Industry Rules & Regulations. message. Shopify Payments Chargeback Reason Code #2: Transaction UnrecognizedChargeback Reason Codes List for American Express. 71 Declined authorization; 72 No authorization obtained; 73 Expired card; 74 Late presentment; 75 Cardholder does not. Chargeback time frames - A specific period during which a chargeback can be raised. Signifyd’s Revenue Protection solution offers fraud screening services to help merchant subscribers protect against fraudulent or unauthorized activity with respect to certain e-commerce transactions, as classified by the applicable card processor’s chargeback. Visa chargeback reason codes are used to categorize the reasons for a chargeback. Merchant must provide proof of authorization. instead of chargeback reason codes Chapter 3—Dual Message System Chargebacks, Overview, Chargeback Message Reason Codes, First Chargeback: MTI 1442 Removed all references to chargeback message reason code 4802—Requested/Required Information Illegible or Missing as announced in Global Security Bulletin No. Discover is a credit card network and an issuing bank—just like American Express. Thanks for following the Chargeback Gurus blog. 4853 – Cardholder Dispute – Credit Not Processed. Chargeback Reason Codes; BIN Lookup; ROI Tool; Company. If the merchant continues to bill the customer, the customer may file a chargeback with American Express under Reason Code 71. The Merchant Reviews the Partial Chargeback Claim. . The most comprehensive guide to chargeback reason codes. • Chargeback Reason Code – Each chargeback contains a reason code that signifies the reason for the dispute and the rules that must be followed by the issuer and the merchant in order to resolve the dispute. The shorthand description is “Card Recovery Bulletin. 16, 2021. A transaction modifier (or modifier) represents specific circumstances associated with a card sale that change what compelling evidence is required to overturn the chargeback. Either the acquiring or issuing bank could initiate the. To. However, the disputes themselves are still categorized by the issuing bank based on the card network issuing the card. If they think it does, they assign it a reason code and credit the funds back to the cardholder’s account. Say Goodbye to. Excessive Chargebacks: The merchant exceeded established chargeback thresholds. ” This code indicates that the merchant sent an authorization approval request for a transaction, received a “Decline” or “Pick Up Card”. 100- 140 standards- , and will be removed in future releases. It comes into play when customers assert non-receipt of goods or services. Accessed October 17,. 2: No Authorization. Visa chargeback reason code 71 falls under the “Authorization” category. Cardholder-Activated Terminal (CAT) 3 Device. Prevention strategy: Implement EMV chip card technology to reduce the risk of fraudulent card-present transactions. Change of Chargeback Reason to an Authorization-related Chargeback Replace ‘Change of Reason within the Cardholder Dispute Chargeback’ with this section. Betty's issuing bank assigned chargeback reason code 10. Know these five rules to avoid payroll blunders triggering fines, penalties and IRS audits. ; Help Center Find answers to common questions about Midigator’s technology,. Below are the top causes of chargebacks including the reason codes established by leading credit card companies: Customer Dissatisfaction: Cardholder did not receive the items/service purchased, the products/services were not as described and/or product (s) was damaged or otherwise defective. It’s important to look up the code to understand why a transaction, good, or service was disputed in order to properly present a solid case to win the chargeback. 1 falls under the “Processing Errors” category. Now, 10. • Section 4: Chargeback Reason Codes—Contains detailed information on the reason codes for the most common types of chargebacks that merchants receive. Then they instruct the merchant’s acquiring bank to reverse the transaction and withdraw the funds from the merchant account. This is commonly caused by either true fraud or friendly fraud. The details below are intended to help businesses feel more confident in understanding common chargeback codes and to surface possible actions you can take to respond to a chargeback dispute. At Visa they used to receive reason code 98. Specifically, these updates only pertain to transactions that are charged back after Oct. Merchant processed transaction below floor limit without authorization. 2? Visa chargeback reason code 11. 3. Unlike other. Reason codes are alphanumeric codes that provide the justification for granting a chargeback. Authorization Category Codes. The shorthand description is “Declined Authorization. Get your complete guide to Mastercard reason codes, including all the detailed information, chargeback time limits, and other important information you need. If you need additional information, visit the additional resources provided at the bottom of this page or at Chargeback. A Merchant Outlet is identified in the Global Merchant Chargeback Monitoring Program if it meets or exceeds all of the following monthly performance activity levels:. A chargeback happens when a customer requests for a transaction to be reversed. 1002 - Cardholder disputes billed amount. F01. 755. Some credit card companies also include a short phrase describing the code and chargeback. 71: Authorization Request Declined / Declined Authorization: 72: No Authorization / Transaction Exceeds Floor Limit: 73: Expired Card: 74: Late Presentment: 75:Try Shopify free for 3 days, no credit card required. If one member believed the other violated a Visa rule when handling a chargeback, they filed a pre-compliance chargeback for compensation. 3: Goods or services were not as described: C31: RM: 13. For each reason code, a definition is provided along with the merchant’s actions—or failure to act—that may have caused the chargeback, and. 1. What are the odds a merchant will “win” the chargeback dispute? The true odds depend on the strength of the compelling evidence and the chargeback reason code itself. ” This reason indicates a merchant sent an authorization approval request for a transaction, received a “Decline” or “Pick Up Card” response, but submitted the. Knowing these codes can help you dispute chargebacks more effectively. 2. '60 days from the Retrieval Request Date Health Care Request 70 Chip Liability Shift 71 Chip/PIN Liability. 195 Acquirer Use of Message Reason Code 7627-No MAC Provided. 11, 16. You can learn more about each one by visiting the Mastercard Chargeback Guide. Because it’s so easy for customers to initiate a chargeback, retailers are bound to experience a request at. 2 Added chapter providing information about the DiscoverIf a dispute has a strong enough basis to warrant a chargeback, Discover will send a chargeback notice to the merchant along with the reason code for the chargeback. With that said, you still need to understand the reason codes with any chargebacks from Amex. 2. The chargeback process is initiated outside of Venmo, between the card issuer and their cardholder. Mastercard Chargeback Reason Codes. 4853 – Cardholder Dispute – Goods or Services Not as Described or Defective. This extra step can be frustrating for Card Members and lead to lost sales. . With the chargeback code in hand, the merchant can now review the transaction. A chargeback is the reversal of a sale transaction that arises from a processing technicality, a customer dispute or fraudulent activity. There are multiple situations in which this can occur. Like traditional chargeback reason codes, an ACH return code indicates why the RDFI initiated the transaction reversal request. 4853 – Cardholder Dispute – Goods or Services Not as Described or Defective. 71 (1) 11.